Degree of Financial Leverage (DFL): A Key to Unlocking Earnings Volatility

In the world of finance, understanding the concept of leverage is pivotal to decision-making. Among the multitude of leverage metrics, the Degree of Financial Leverage (DFL) stands as a powerful indicator of a company's financial health. This article delves deep into the concept of DFL, how it affects the volatility of earnings, and why its prudent analysis is crucial for investment decisions.

Degree of Financial Leverage (DFL)

At its core, the Degree of Financial Leverage (DFL) serves as a financial ratio assessing the impact of capital structure changes on a company's Earnings Per Share (EPS). It quantifies the sensitivity of EPS to fluctuations in operating income, technically termed as Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT).

Understanding the Implications of DFL

The DFL ratio unveils a fundamental principle: the higher the DFL, the more susceptible earnings become to market volatility. A company with a high DFL leverages the power of fixed expenses like interest, magnifying returns, and consequently, EPS. This can be advantageous during periods of economic prosperity and growth, as the increase in operating income boosts EPS. Conversely, in tough economic climates, when operating income takes a hit, a high DFL can have adverse effects.

DFL Formulas: A Closer Look

To further illustrate, let's understand the DFL calculation. The simplest way to compute DFL is to divide the percentage change in EPS by the percentage change in EBIT:

Alternatively, DFL can be computed using the following equation:

DFL = EBIT / (EBIT - Interest)

Deciphering What DFL Conveys

The value of DFL extends beyond the simple volatility of earnings. It serves as an invaluable tool for a company to gauge the optimal level of debt or financial leverage within its capital structure.

For instance, a company with stable operating income can manage a higher level of debt without unsettling earnings and EPS. This means a high DFL might be acceptable. On the other hand, for companies in sectors where operating income is prone to volatility, a lower DFL, indicating a manageable level of debt, is often the safer route.

Industries exhibit varying levels of financial leverage usage. Retail stores, airlines, and banking institutions, among others, are known to operate under high financial leverage. Regrettably, excessive financial leverage has led many businesses in these sectors to resort to Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

Prominent examples include R.H. Macy (1992), Trans World Airlines (2001), Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co (A&P) (2010) and Midwest Generation (2012). The U.S. financial crisis between 2007 and 2009, with the collapse of Lehman Brothers (2008) and several other leveraged institutions, underscored the destructive power of excessive financial leverage.

The Real-World Application of DFL: A Case Study

To see DFL in action, let's take a real-world example from 2021 involving Tesla Inc., a high-growth company in the electric vehicle industry. In 2021, Tesla reported an operating income (EBIT) of $5.3 billion, with interest expenses amounting to approximately $110 million. With nearly 963 million shares outstanding, the EPS came out to be around $3.12.

Given these numbers, we can use the second formula to calculate Tesla's DFL:

DFL = EBIT / (EBIT - Interest)

= $5.3 billion / ($5.3 billion - $110 million)

= 1.021

The DFL of 1.021 suggests that for every 1% change in EBIT, the EPS would change by approximately 1.021%, displaying a relatively low sensitivity of EPS to operating income. This indicated that despite its aggressive growth strategy, Tesla had managed to maintain a balanced capital structure, making it an attractive prospect for investors in 2021.

Delving Deeper: Variations in the Use of Financial Leverage

Financial leverage can be a boon or a bane, depending on its use. It's a strategic tool, often used differently across various industries and business sectors. For instance, retail stores and airlines frequently operate with high degrees of financial leverage. While this can generate substantial profits in periods of growth, it can also lead to financial instability during economic downturns.

Utility companies and banking institutions also routinely maintain high leverage. These sectors typically have predictable cash flows and stable earnings, which can tolerate high leverage. However, the overuse of financial leverage can potentially lead to financial distress and bankruptcy.

Regrettably, history provides several examples of companies whose excessive use of financial leverage forced them to file for bankruptcy. Remember R.H. Macy in 1992, Trans World Airlines in 2001, the Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co (A&P) in 2010, and Midwest Generation in 2012? All these businesses were victims of high financial leverage.

One of the most devastating examples of high leverage misuse was the U.S. financial crisis of 2007-2009. The collapse of highly leveraged financial institutions such as Lehman Brothers in 2008 starkly highlighted the risks of excessive financial leverage. Therefore, prudent use of leverage is a delicate balancing act that businesses must perform.

Let's Talk Numbers: Another Practical Example of DFL Application

To understand the real-world application of DFL, let's consider a case study involving Netflix, the renowned streaming giant. According to Netflix's 2021 financial statements, the company's operating income (EBIT) was around $4.585 billion, and its interest expense was $690 million.

Using these values in our DFL formula:

DFL = EBIT / (EBIT - Interest)

= $4.585 billion / ($4.585 billion - $690 million)

= 1.179

In this case, a 1% change in operating income would cause approximately a 1.179% change in Netflix earnings per share (EPS), suggesting a moderate degree of financial leverage. As a result, investors in 2021 might have seen Netflix as a relatively stable investment, as the company managed to balance its growth strategy with the risks associated with financial leverage.

Fact Check: Fun Facts about DFL and Financial Leverage

• A Double-Edged Sword:  Financial leverage, represented by metrics like DFL, can increase a company's return on equity and earnings per share. But remember, it can also intensify the impact of operating income fluctuations on earnings per share, making it a double-edged sword.
• Dependence on Industry Stability:  Companies in industries with stable cash flows and predictable earnings, such as utilities, often operate with higher degrees of financial leverage. However, industries susceptible to market volatility usually adopt lower leverage to mitigate risk.
• A Predictor of Risk:  High DFL can be an indicator of higher financial risk. Therefore, businesses operating in volatile markets need to maintain lower DFLs to manage financial risk effectively.

Conclusion

To encapsulate, the Degree of Financial Leverage (DFL) is a powerful financial metric that measures the effect of changes in a company's capital structure on its EPS. By providing insights into earnings volatility and the company's ability to handle debt, DFL serves as a critical tool for investors to make informed decisions.

The Degree of Financial Leverage (DFL) measures how a company's earnings per share (EPS) react to changes in its operating income. It's an insightful metric that helps evaluate a company's debt levels in its capital structure. The higher the DFL, the more the EPS will respond to changes in operating income. While this can be beneficial in a growing economy, it can also expose the company to risks during downturns. The calculated DFL of Tesla in 2021 demonstrated a well-balanced capital structure, making it an appealing investment choice.

---

• Share this article

---

Discover Related Articles